How to achieve hiring criteria alignment in the recruitment process
2 minute read
Posted by Emily Hill on 13 December 2023
Ensuring alignment among stakeholders on hiring criteria is paramount for an efficient, equitable, and successful recruitment process. Misalignment can lead to hiring the wrong candidates or erroneously rejecting strong candidates, resulting in prolonged hiring timelines and unnecessary friction.
Here, Chris Platts, CEO at ThriveMap, talks through a streamlined approach to achieve alignment among different stakeholders:
1. Conduct a job analysis
A job analysis involves studying the role to determine what attributes (skills, knowledge, behaviors) are actually required for success. This ensures your criteria are based on realistic job requirements rather than assumptions. This can be done through shadowing, surveys, and or employee interviews. You can use a simple tool like Signal to guide your job analysis process.
2. Map out your stakeholders
Brainstorm with all the decision makers in the hiring process from hiring managers to interviewers to trainers. Analyse each stakeholder’s level of influence and interest in the hiring outcomes. Identify detractors and their potential concerns.
3. Hold a workshop
Bring your mapped stakeholders into an alignment workshop. At ThriveMap we call these “Ideal Candidate Profile” workshops. Present the findings from your job analysis as the basis for the discussion but let all stakeholders contribute their opinions on any attributes that may have been overlooked. First, get agreement on the key attributes, next for each attribute, agree clear definitions and behavioral indicators. Capture examples of positive and negative demonstration of the attributes, preferably in observable job-based scenarios.
4. Confirm assessment approach
Decide how you will assess each criteria – what interview questions, assessment center exercises, tests etc. The assessment methods need to allow candidates to demonstrate the agreed criteria. Share examples and scenarios that map to the criteria to calibrate your stakeholders on consistent rating.
5. Continuously improve
Analyse post-hire performance data about hiring criteria to determine what attributes correlate with success. Refine your criteria and alignment approach based on this analysis to achieve better outcomes over time.
Ongoing stakeholder communication, education and data-driven refinement are key to maintaining alignment on your hiring criteria as jobs evolve.
Subscribe for insights, debunks and what amounts to a free, up-to-date recruitment toolkit.
ThriveMap creates customised assessments for high volume roles, which take candidates through an online “day in the life” experience of work in your company. Our assessments have been proven to reduce staff turnover, reduce time to hire, and improve quality of hire.
Not sure what type of assessment is right for your business? Read our guide.
Other articles you might be interested in
Navigating recruitment technology compliance: Key considerations and how to future-proof your investments
Recruitment technology is rapidly evolving and regulators across the world are playing catch up to ensure candidates are getting a fair experience. This article discusses the key considerations that you, as a recruitment leader, must consider before investing in new tools, to both future-proof from impending regulations and to uphold equality, inclusion, and diversity in […]
In the rapidly evolving job market, skills-based hiring is becoming increasingly significant, heralding what some call the “death of the degree.” With technology advancing at breakneck speed, employees find themselves in a constant cycle of acquiring new skills to stay relevant. This shift has led many job seekers and employers alike to prioritize skills and […]
Try This Candidate Testimonial Template & Get Rave Hiring Reviews
Imagine this: A potential candidate is browsing your company’s career page, intrigued by the career opportunities and the culture you’re promoting. They’re impressed by what they see, but they’re worried that the hiring process is going to be long and cumbersome. Before applying for a job, they need something more convincing: powerful candidate testimonials. Let’s […]