How to Create an AI-Proof Pre-Screening Assessment

3 minute read

Posted by Emily Hill on 22 October 2024

Whether you’re ready or not, AI is shaking up the recruitment process like never before.

To stay ahead of the curve, it’s essential to adopt better pre-screening practices.

If you’re considering using pre-hire assessments, here are some important dos and don’ts to help you create an AI-proof pre-screening process:

What Not to Do

1. Use open-text questions

Avoid: Questions that require written open-text responses can easily be answered by generative AI. These responses often lack the nuance and personal touch that reflect true candidate capabilities.

2. Use generic, pre-existing questions

Avoid: Relying on generic questions that are already available on the internet can make it easier for AI to provide pre-prepared answers. These questions may not accurately assess the candidate’s fit for your specific role.

3. Incorporate easily answered non-contextual questions

Avoid: Questions that are straightforward and can be answered with basic knowledge, such as standard maths problems, do not provide insight into a candidate’s actual abilities or fit.

4. Depend on generative AI-created questions

Avoid: Questions that have been generated by AI can often be recognised and answered by other AI systems, which reduces their effectiveness as a screening tool.

5. Focus solely on knowledge recall

Avoid: Assessments that focus purely on recalling facts, trivia, or definitions may not gauge a candidate’s practical skills or critical thinking abilities.

What to Do

1. Use multiple-choice, situational, or interactive assessments

Do: Design assessments that involve multiple-choice questions or situational tasks. These formats make it more difficult for AI to generate suitable responses, as they require deeper engagement with the material.

2. Develop nuanced, company-specific questions

Do: Create unique questions that reflect real-world scenarios relevant to your organisation. Tailoring questions to your specific needs makes it harder for candidates to rely on generic AI-generated responses.

3. Focus on context-rich, job-specific tasks

Do: Implement context-rich questions or situational judgement scenarios. These types of assessments require human judgement and a thorough understanding of the role, making them less predictable for AI.

4. Create custom, human-generated questions

Do: Design questions that require creative problem-solving or critical thinking. These assessments should reflect the unique challenges faced by your company, providing better insight into a candidate’s abilities.

5. Implement assessments that require applied knowledge

Do: Consider assessments that focus on problem-solving exercises tied to real-world tasks. This not only assesses candidates’ knowledge but also their ability to apply it in practical situations.

6. Use job simulations

Do: Incorporate job simulations that allow candidates to demonstrate practical skills in scenarios that mimic actual job responsibilities. This approach helps ensure that you are evaluating their capabilities in a relevant context.

Next Steps: Supercharge Your Recruitment Process

Whether you’re ready or not, AI is shaking up recruitment like never before. That’s why it’s essential to ensure your pre-screening assessments effectively identify candidates with the right skills, fit, and commitment.

With ThriveMap’s bespoke ‘day-in-the-life’ job assessments and analytics tools, you’ll be well-equipped to uncover candidates’ true potential. This not only makes your recruitment process faster and more effective but also predictive of future success—helping to reduce attrition and improve the quality of hire.

Get a demo here: https://thrivemap.io/demo/

Share

The ThriveMap Newsroom

Subscribe for insights, debunks and what amounts to a free, up-to-date recruitment toolkit.

About ThriveMap

ThriveMap creates customised assessments for high volume roles, which take candidates through an online “day in the life” experience of work in your company. Our assessments have been proven to reduce staff turnover, reduce time to hire, and improve quality of hire.

Not sure what type of assessment is right for your business? Read our guide.

Other articles you might be interested in

Banner image for this post

Best Talent Assessment Platforms in 2025: Features, Benefits, and How to Choose

In 2025, recruiters are navigating a hiring landscape unlike anything before. AI-enabled candidates are flooding the pipeline, making it harder than ever to distinguish genuine talent from algorithmically optimised applicants. With job applications skyrocketing and AI-generated resumes perfectly tailored to keyword scans, recruiters must stay one step ahead with smarter assessment tools to ensure quality […]

Continue reading
Banner image for this post

The “Great Expectation Mismatch”: Why Job Descriptions Are Just Fairy Tales in Disguise

Imagine If Job Descriptions Were as Misleading as Online Dating Profiles—Oh Wait, They Already Are There’s a reason why 55% of employees have quit a job due to a disconnect between the job’s portrayal in the recruitment process and the actual experience—a 15% increase since 2019, according to ThriveMap’s latest research. The hiring process is […]

Continue reading
Banner image for this post

The 3 best pre-Hire assessment Tools for graduate recruitment in 2025

The recruitment landscape is being reshaped by artificial intelligence, and hiring teams must adapt to stay ahead. This is particularly true in graduate recruitment, where over 50% of candidates are already using AI tools. The result? Recruitment processes are becoming faster, more competitive, and harder to navigate. For recruiters using pre-hire assessment tools, the rise […]

Continue reading

View all articles