Should I design my pre-hire assessment using ChatGPT?

5 minute read

Posted by Emily Hill on 16 January 2025

The buzz around AI tools like ChatGPT is hard to ignore—and for good reason. ChatGPT is an impressive (and free!) tool that can generate ideas, analyse data and produce content rapidly. But when it comes to designing your pre-hire assessment questions, can ChatGPT do it justice?

Let’s explore the possibilities, limitations, and why partnering with an expert provider might be your best bet for creating effective, contextually relevant, and secure pre-hire assessments.

What ChatGPT does really well

ChatGPT is a powerful AI tool that can enhance your recruitment process in several ways:

Automating repetitive tasks
Need help generating social media posts for job openings or drafting FAQs about your hiring process? ChatGPT can handle repetitive, text-based tasks, freeing up your team to focus on more strategic initiatives.

Brainstorming recruitment ideas
Need inspiration for your hiring process? ChatGPT can quickly generate ideas for job descriptions, interview questions, or even candidate communication templates. For instance, it can suggest creative ways to structure your candidate outreach emails or provide a starting point for job ads tailored to different roles.

Improving candidate communication
From drafting offer letters to crafting rejection emails, ChatGPT helps save time by generating polished, professional messages. With a little tweaking, you can ensure your tone reflects your company’s brand while delivering clear and empathetic communication.

Cost-effective support
One of ChatGPT’s biggest advantages is that it’s free to use (or low-cost with premium options). For smaller companies or startups, this makes it an accessible tool to streamline parts of the hiring process without requiring a hefty budget.

The limitations of ChatGPT for pre-hire assessments

Relying on ChatGPT to design pre-hire assessment questions comes with significant risks and drawbacks:

1. Lack of contextual relevance

ChatGPT generates content based on patterns in the data it has been trained on, not on your company’s unique context. This means that while it might create general questions, they’re unlikely to reflect the specific tasks, challenges, or culture of your organisation, which is essential when finding the best person for your job.

2. Vulnerability to AI gaming

Candidates are becoming more adept at using tools like ChatGPT themselves. If your assessment questions are generic, they can easily be gamed by candidates using similar AI tools to craft their answers. This undermines the validity of your assessment and may lead to hiring individuals who aren’t genuinely the best fit for the role.

Read How to create an AI-proof pre-screening assessment

3. Lack of a professional experience

Creating an assessment is more than just writing questions—it’s about delivering an immersive, interactive and engaging candidate experience. A ChatGPT-generated assessment might feel disjointed or amateurish without proper formatting, branding, or an intuitive interface.

4. No validation or compliance

Pre-hire assessments need to be legally compliant and backed by research to ensure they’re fair and effective. ChatGPT lacks the ability to validate its questions or ensure compliance with employment laws, potentially exposing your company to legal risks.

The case for a bespoke assessment

This is where partnering with an expert provider, like ThriveMap, makes a huge difference. While ChatGPT offers a quick and easy way to generate content, professional assessment platforms bring added value that’s hard to replicate:

1. Contextually relevant and job-specific assessments

Expert providers specialise in creating assessments that reflect your real tasks, challenges, and culture. This contextual relevance ensures that the questions aren’t just generic—they directly measure the skills and behaviors required to excel in the role.

Winconton job simulation

2. Beautiful, branded candidate portals

A professionally designed candidate portal creates a polished and engaging experience. With features like your company’s branding, intuitive navigation, and real-time feedback, candidates are more likely to view your hiring process positively.

welcome candidates prehire assessment

3. AI-resistant design

Unlike off-the-shelf or AI-generated questions, custom assessment questions are crafted to be resistant to gaming. By incorporating dynamic, scenario-based tasks and requiring candidates to apply their knowledge in real-time, expert-designed assessments ensure authenticity.

realistic pre hire assessments

4. Hiring criteria alignment through Job Analysis

One of ThriveMap’s key advantages lies in its ability to ensure hiring criteria alignment through comprehensive job analysis: surveys, workshops, and ongoing collaboration. By deeply understanding the specific requirements, tasks, and behaviours essential for success in each role, we design assessments that measure what truly matters. This tailored approach ensures that your pre-hire assessments are not only contextually relevant but also aligned with the unique needs of your organisation—giving you confidence in every hiring decision.

5. Ongoing validation and compliance

We are able to demonstrate our assessments are reliable and predictive. This reduces the risk of adverse impact and ensures you’re hiring based on scientifically sound methods.

6. Time savings without the guesswork

With a provider like ThriveMap, you’re not left guessing if your questions are effective or fair. Our expertise ensures the assessment is ready to go—saving you the time and effort of trial and error.

7. Continuous improvement through data-driven insights


At ThriveMap, we continuously refine your pre-hire assessment using a data-driven approach. By analysing performance insights and feedback from both candidates and employers, we ensure our assessments remain predictive, relevant, and fair over time. This commitment to continuous improvement, paired with our dedication to measurable results, is why 98% of our customers choose to stay with us year after year. With ThriveMap, you’re not just getting a one-time solution—you’re investing in a hiring process that evolves and improves alongside your organisation.

highested rated pre-hire job assessment tool

For a powerful, predictive pre-hire assessment, choose Realistic Job Assessments

Don’t settle for generic solutions that can leave you exposed to risk and inefficiencies. With ThriveMap, you’re future-proofing your hiring process.

Act now to stay ahead. Book a demo today aBook a demo today and discover how ThriveMap can transform your hiring process into your company’s biggest competitive advantage. Don’t settle for “good enough” when your hiring success deserves the best. Let’s revolutionize the way you hire, one great candidate at a time.

https://thrivemap.io/book-demo/

Share

The ThriveMap Newsroom

Subscribe for insights, debunks and what amounts to a free, up-to-date recruitment toolkit.

About ThriveMap

ThriveMap creates customised assessments for high volume roles, which take candidates through an online “day in the life” experience of work in your company. Our assessments have been proven to reduce staff turnover, reduce time to hire, and improve quality of hire.

Not sure what type of assessment is right for your business? Read our guide.

Other articles you might be interested in

Banner image for this post

How to Hire the Best-Fit Customer Experience Advisors at Scale

Recruiting a team of exceptional customer experience advisors requires precision. Why? Because these hires directly influence customer loyalty, brand reputation, and, ultimately, business growth. But here’s the challenge: no two customer experience advisor roles are alike. What works for one organisation may not be effective for another. Without clarity on the skills that truly matter, […]

Continue reading
Banner image for this post

How to Draft a High-Volume Pre-Hire Assessment Tender

When you’re responsible for recruiting at scale, finding the right pre-hire assessment solution can be the difference between a streamlined hiring process and a logistical nightmare. Drafting a tender for high-volume pre-hire assessments is an opportunity to set clear expectations for vendors while ensuring the solution you select truly meets your organization’s needs. Here are […]

Continue reading
Banner image for this post

How to tackle attrition in hiring

Attrition is often the silent drain on recruitment efforts, impacting businesses in ways that are too costly to ignore. From inflated hiring budgets to declining team morale, productivity, and customer satisfaction, the effects of attrition ripple across the organisation. Yet, it’s rarely tackled head-on. The reality? Attrition isn’t just a recruitment challenge; it’s a business-wide […]

Continue reading

View all articles