2023 guide to what frontline candidates expect from pre-hire processes

2 minute read

Posted by Emily Hill on 13 September 2023

Candid feedback often surfaces on platforms like Glassdoor, where candidates freely share their experiential discontent.

Some of these reviews can carry a real sting.

You can’t always please everyone. But it is important to be able to identify potential vulnerabilities within your pre-hire process to avoid unfavourable reviews that could potentially tarnish your company’s reputation.

What might be your company’s internal processes, may be off-putting for candidates and giving them a negative impression of the business.

So, we were curious – what do frontline candidate expect from recruitment processes in 2023

Harnessing the power of AI, we analysed 100’s of negative Glassdoor reviews for frontline roles such as those in hospitality, customer service, and fast-food, to understand what exactly fuels dissatisfaction.

Here’s the top 5 issues we uncovered.

We hope by providing these insights, you can stay one step ahead of getting bad Glassdoor reviews.

1. Extended interview processes:

Warning prehire assessment iconCandidates seem to value speed above all. Instances where interview procedures prove excessively lengthy or intricate in relation to the job’s nature seems to breed the most frustration.

2. Lack of follow-up perception:
Finding the right candidates icon

Lack of follow-up not only leaves candidates in the dark about their application status but also sends a message that their time and effort aren’t valued.

3. Excessive paperwork:

questions to ask during the pre-hire assessment process icon

Requiring extensive CVs, lengthy assessments, and detailed covering letters can frustrate candidates who seek a streamlined and efficient application process. The frustration stemming from cumbersome paperwork leads potential hires to question whether the administrative burden reflects the actual nature of the job.

4. Expectation misalignment:

automate candidate assessment process. candidate pools

In the world of frontline roles, where agility and adaptability are key, many candidates expressed frustration when facing interview questions that seem out of sync with the entry-level nature of the position. Redundant queries about prior experiences can lead to a mismatch between candidate expectations and the actual responsibilities of the role. This misalignment not only disengages potential candidates but also indicates a potential communication gap between the recruitment process and the role’s true demands.

5. Predictable questions that aren’t relevant:

automate candidate assessment process. candidate pools

When it comes to making a lasting impression, the questions posed during interviews wield considerable influence.

Interestingly, candidates often point out their dissatisfaction with commonplace and predictable interview questions. This insight suggests a desire for thought-provoking questions that not only challenge candidates but also provide them with the opportunity to showcase their unique qualities.


Need to revamp your pre-hiring procedure?

When it comes to selecting candidates for frontline positions, the inner workings of your process often remain hidden from their view. Coordinating interviews, evaluating resumes, and securing approval from hiring managers all happen behind the scenes.

Nevertheless, the candidate experience holds greater significance than ever before. If you find your process to be cumbersome and ineffective, chances are your candidates share that sentiment—even if they haven’t voiced their concerns on platforms like Glassdoor just yet.

In response, numerous businesses are turning to Realistic Job Assessments as a new approach to their pre-hire evaluations, especially for roles where traditional methods such as CV reviews, phone screenings, and game-based assessments are no longer as relevant. Realistic Job Assessments have demonstrated improvements in hiring diversity, reduced time-to-hire, and enhanced on-the-job performance. This, in turn, leads to lower turnover rates and more positive feedback about the hiring process.

Best practice pre-hire assessment process

Read more on Realistic Job Assessments here: thrivemap.io/realistic-job-assessment/


The ThriveMap Newsroom

Subscribe for insights, debunks and what amounts to a free, up-to-date recruitment toolkit.

About ThriveMap

ThriveMap creates customised assessments for high volume roles, which take candidates through an online “day in the life” experience of work in your company. Our assessments have been proven to reduce staff turnover, reduce time to hire, and improve quality of hire.

Not sure what type of assessment is right for your business? Read our guide.

Other articles you might be interested in

Banner image for this post

Three example best practices to elevate your candidate experience

Looking to improve your candidate experience? You’re in the right place. In this article, we’ve compiled three “best practice” examples implemented by hiring teams to improve candidate experience. But first, we’ll define what candidate experience is and explore its significance in achieving a well-oiled recruitment machine. Let’s go. What is candidate experience, and why does […]

Continue reading
Banner image for this post

How to Hire Emotionally Intelligent People: Lap of Love Spotlight

It’s said that there are nine categories of intelligence. This means that while some individuals might excel in the structured world of mathematics, others will master more physical tasks, and so on. When it comes to recruiting people with certain forms of intelligence, one type of intelligence isn’t easy to identify from screening a CV […]

Continue reading
Banner image for this post

Does your pre-hire assessment tool require a bias audit?

Introduction If you’re a recruiter leveraging artificial intelligence (AI), a resume screening tool, or other automated methods in your pre-hire assessment, new regulations such as NYC Law 144, may impact your practices.  NYC Law 144 is the pioneering regulation that prohibits the use of Automated Employee Decision Tools (AEDT) to screen candidates or employees based […]

Continue reading

View all articles